history

How Black Bears Returned to Kansas Script

At the dawn of the 19th-century, Kansas was a very different place. Buffalo roamed while deer and antelope played. Black bears lived alongside them.

You might be surprised but it’s true!

            They lived in riparian zones along rivers and creeks where bears had plenty of food and shelter. Unfortunately, people wanted to live in the same areas. Proximity bred conflict and the bears lost. Badly. 

You’ll have to keep watching to find out why they disappeared and how we brought them back! It’s a classic American conservation story.  

            The why is simple. Thanks to human wildlife conflict black bears were hunted off the Kansas prairies by the 1880s. Stories like this one in 1866 happened across the state.

            In October, The Daily Kansas Tribune reported that Mr. Fisher killed a bear on the Cottonwood River. The bear was just strolling up the river in the heart of the tall grass prairie.  

In a scene out of Frankenstein, Mr. Fisher, Jonathan Wood, and others banded together to kill the bear. By all accounts I could find it was peaceful.

            People actually thought it was someone’s pet.[1]

            Dick Stevenson’s hunt in 1872 drew state wide attention. He was a Sumner County commissioner and shot a 400 pound bear in Barbour County.[2]  

            Three years later another bear made state wide news. That time, a black bear visited Mr. Bird’s garden in Arkansas City. The Atchison Daily Patriot reported that it was spotted on a Sunday morning. That’s quite a surprise on the way to church![3]

            I’m sure the bear was dead within a few days of that encounter.

            Just like the European colonizers before them, Americans weren’t big fans of toothy critters. If you’ve watched my videos before, you’ll know that is an understatement.

            They hunted everything that remotely poised a threat to humans. Even though black bears are pretty safe, they were a prime target. Between safety concerns, predation on domestic animals, and blood lust the bears had to go.

            Death and destruction is only half the story though. The other is hopeful thanks to Arkansas.

            Arkansas took one of America’s worst examples of market hunting and turned it into a very successful conservation win.

             It all started in the 1950s when Arkansas decided to reintroduce black bears after centuries of overhunting.

            Bear oil was an important historic commodity in Arkansas. Biologists with the University of Arkansas at Little Rock estimated that thousands of bears were killed every year for the oil alone.[4] Bears had dollar signs carved into their back. By the mid 1900s they were almost gone.

            In 1957, biologists drove a few male young bears down from Minnesota and Canada. Over the next 11 years they released 260 bears into good habitat far away from humans.

            The males needed time to establish territories so females weren’t introduced for a decade. Once that happened, the population slowly recovered. By 1980, bears had recovered enough that the state opened a limited hunting season for bears.[5]

            Over the next several decades those bears expanded out of Arkansas. In 2009, Oklahoma opened its first black bear hunting season. In 2021, Missouri joined the party with a limited black bear hunt.

            By mid 2010s, bears were spotted in Kansas as well. Every spring, more and more bears make their way into Kansas to reclaim their historic territory on the tall grass prairies. 

            So far there are no known breeding populations but someone captured a bear cub on a home security camera in Winfield, Kansas in 2022.[6] In 2023, someone spotted a bear just south of Kansas City in Cass County, Missouri.[7]

            According to Jeff Ford a biologists with the Oklahoma Department of Wildlife, young males can range up to 150 miles away from their core habitat.[8]

            For now, the bears in Kansas are younger males but if females wonder north biologists in Kansas believe they could establish a breeding population.[9]

            We won’t see many predators come back to the prairies but any animals that return should be celebrated. Environmental historian Dan Flores called the 19th-century over hunting on the prairies of North American one of the biggest man made ecological disasters in human history. 

            Thanks to the biologists in Arkansas, we have started correcting a part of that disaster. Next time you think about animals we’ve saved, I hope you think of black bears along with the bald eagle, bison, elk, and many others.

Thank you for watching and if you enjoyed this video please subscribe!


[1] https://www.newspapers.com/image/60856253/?match=1&terms=%22black%20bear%22

[2] https://www.newspapers.com/image/80359109/?match=1&terms=%22black%20bear%22

[3] https://www.newspapers.com/image/81218816/?match=1&terms=%22black%20bear%22

[4] Bowers, Annalea K.; Lucio, Leah D.; Clark, David W.; Rakow, Susan P.; and Heidt, Gary A. (2001) "Early History of the Wolf, Black Bear, and Mountain Lion in Arkansas," Journal of the Arkansas Academy of Science: Vol. 55, Article 4. Available at: https://scholarworks.uark.edu/jaas/vol55/iss1/4

[5] https://news.uark.edu/articles/9023/arkansas-black-bear-reintroduction-one-of-most-successful-in-the-world-ua-researcher-says

[6] https://www.kansascity.com/news/state/kansas/article257771258.html

[7] https://www.kake.com/story/49051293/black-bear-sighting-confirmed-near-kansas-city

[8] https://www.wibw.com/2020/07/14/black-bears-appearing-in-kansas/

[9] https://www.cjonline.com/story/news/2017/08/16/wild-black-bear-population-grows-kansas/16533058007/

History of Coyote Bounties! Script

Coyotes are an American original. They evolved in North America one to two million years ago in the heart of the Pleistocene Epoch. Their world had North American hyenas, dire wolves, and sabertooth cats, among other predators. They became omnivores and master survivalists in that world, and those adaptations served them well when another predator showed up in North America about 12,000 years ago. Us. 

We co-existed fairly peacefully for most of humanity's history on this continent. In many Native American religions, coyotes were revered as trickster gods. They were responsible for everything from unleashing buffalo onto the Great Plains to providing fire. Euro-Americans shattered that co-existences when they started an all-out war on coyotes. 

In today’s video, I’ll discuss the first salvos of that war, coyote bounties. We’ll cover the history, why bounties were misguided, and how much money states wasted on them. Before we continue, please like and subscribe to learn more about North American wildlife history. 

Bounties have a long history in the United States. The story began in 1630 when the Massasschutes Bay Colony placed a bounty on wolves. Bounties were a tool to incentivize people to kill more animals. Europeans passed their hatred of wolves onto future generations through oral storytelling like Little Red Riding Hood. 

As settlers moved west, they brought diseases, livestock, and a disdain for predators. When they encountered coyotes, they confused the animals with wolves. Merriweather Lewis described coyotes as “prairie wolves” in his journal. The name stuck, and people have associated wolves with coyotes ever since. 

The earliest record of coyote bounties I could find is in Missouri in 1825. In Kansas, the state government passed the first bounty law in 1877 that applied a 1 dollar bounty to each scalp. Today, one coyote would be worth around 30 dollars. Remember the dollar amount because it will be important later in this video. 

The hatred for coyotes was based in part on false assumptions about their diet. Many people believed that coyotes eat larger game or domestic species like deer, cows, etc, that humans rely on. While they occasionally eat those animals, it has been shown in many studies that coyotes typically eat smaller prey that many humans consider pests.

 A biologist for the National Parks Service named Adolph Murie conducted one of those early studies in 1940. In “Ecology of the Coyotes in the Yellowstone” Murie concluded that coyotes mainly consumed small mammals, birds, and a variety of smaller prey like fish, reptiles, and insects. Basically, they’ll eat whatever they can find whenever they can find it . 

Despite the misunderstanding, states across the western U.S. placed bounties on coyotes in the 19th century. Some states went to extreme lengths to support the bounty. Montana, for example, spent almost two-thirds of its annual budget on wolf and coyote bounty payments between 1883 and 1923.

States wasted a lot of money paying bounties. As we see today, coyotes are still alive and well. They’ve even expanded their range. The bounties failed to wipe out coyotes, and they wasted money in other ways. There are reports of people raising coyotes as farm animals for these bounties.

I searched newspaper archives across the country and found over 1,000 mentions of people raising or farming coyotes for the bounty. It is easy to see why if we look at an example from Oregon. 

Sheep ranching was a significant business in Oregon in the 19th century. However, some ranchers argued they could make more money selling coyote scalps. The Statesman Journal published an article titled “Coyotes VS. Sheep” on 11/27/1894 that argued sheep ranchers should raise coyotes. 

At the time, one sheep was worth around two and a half dollars, and the bounty on coyotes was 6 dollars per scalp. Coyotes also have five to seven pups a year, while ewes only have one or two. As the writer said, “The arithmetic and logic of the matter are easy.” A similar story unfolded in Kansas. 

In 1913, Anderson County discovered that they had suffered fraudulent bounty payments for a number of years. According to an article called “Coyotes Raised for Scalps in the Chanute Weekly Tribune on 05/09/1913, a hunter named W. F. Wells discovered several people were raising coyotes for the scalps. 

These people had caught a breeding pair of coyotes and kept them. The article mentions that a Sunday school superintendent raised the coyotes for years and made 50 dollars in five years. A neighbor got fed with this and stole the coyotes before the superintendent could turn them in. The neighbor collected the one-dollar bounty. 

Another example from Kansas comes in May of 1903 when The Wellington Journal reported that a dozen or more farmers were organizing the “Society for the Prevention of the Destruction of Female Coyotes” or S.P.D.F.C for short. Their goal was to protect female coyotes as breeding stock. 

The writer says that the larger than normal number of bounties being turned in led to “a general suspicion that the bounty business is being worked for all its is worth in this county.” Females were rarely turned in, with “nine out of every ten being young coyotes.” There could be another explanation, however.

The article is scientifically inaccurate because it claims females can have several litters of pups a year. Female coyotes only have one litter, and they typically give birth to four to seven pups, generally born in April or May. The number of pups depends on the how much food is available and the local coyote population. 

The fewer coyotes in an area mean more food is available and more pups are born. Notice when that article was published, late spring. It’s easy to see how someone would suspect foul play when the majority of animals turned in were young pups in May or June. But another likely scenario is hunters found and killed dens when the mother wasn’t around. 

People across the country were suspicious, but we shouldn’t assume that raising coyotes was common. It's possible people simply didn’t believe coyotes could continue to thrive under hunting pressure and made up excuses for their failures to exterminate coyotes. 

Bounties were the start of America’s war on coyotes. In a future video, I’ll discuss the federal government's role in the slaughter. Ultimately, that was a failure as well. Even today, the United States Department of Agriculture estimates that 50,000 coyotes are killed a year. 

They keep expanding and, despite our best attempts over the last couple of hundred years, are still thriving. That is where the power of adapting to an ever-changing landscape helps them. The strategies they employed to live with North American hyenas, dire wolves, and sabertooth cats serve them just as well as living with us. 

Thank you for watching.

Citations

Coyote America, Dan Flores.

Louis and Clark Journal

A Brief Hist A Brief History of Extension Pr y of Extension Predator Contr or Control in Missouri ol in Missouri
The original text of the law was published in the Walnut Valley Times on May 18, 1877. It is also possible to find the text fully cited as a Kansas statute. See Kansas State Board of Agriculture. Biennial Report – Kansas State Board of Agriculture, Volume 1, 584.

 Murie, Adolph. Ecology of the Coyote in the Yellowstone. (Washinton D.C., U.S Government), 1940. 

Predatory Bureaucracy, Michael J Robinson

 Statesman Journal, Coyotes vs Sheep, 11/27/1894. 
 Coyotes Raised for Scalps, Chanute Weekly Tribune, 05/09/1913. 

 The Wellington Journal, 05/09/1903. 

Video Clips

United States Fish and Wildlife Service American Mammals 1

Other footage courtesy of Videvo

Music

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Still Pickin by Kevin MacLeod

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/5707-still-pickin

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

Artist website: https://incompetech.com

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Warm Sunset by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/8070-warm-sunset

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Beautiful Acoustic Guitar Melody by WinnieTheMoog

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/6350-beautiful-acoustic-guitar-melody

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Light Of A Clear Morning by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/7831-light-of-a-clear-morning

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license


The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Acoustic And Mellow (loopable) by chilledmusic

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/8832-acoustic-and-mellow-loopable

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license


The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Breathe Easy And Relax by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/7886-breathe-easy-and-relax

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: When The Sun Sets by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/7904-when-the-sun-sets

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Friends Forever by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/8076-friends-forever

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Working Hard With Desire And Hope by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/6123-working-hard-with-desire-and-hope

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license





KANSAS’ LOST WILDLIFE SCRIPT

KANSAS’ LOST WILDLIFE SCRIPT

In the early 1800s, Americans called Kansas and the Great Plains the North American Desert. They were misled by Major Stephen H. Long and his poor attitude towards the plains during his expedition across North America. To him, the Great Plains was a boring, drab place. Today, many people share his view of this expansive grassland that historically rivaled the African Veldt in terms of biodiversity.

Sadly, Long’s assessment was a prediction. We’ve wiped out most of our megafauna. Environmental historian Dan Flores called the Great Plains pre-Manifest Destiny “one of the marvels of the world.” Today, that marvel means seeing the ghosts of bears, elk, and other animals who called Kansas home before Americans migrated west. 

In today's video, we’ll explore Kansas’ rich environmental history, and I’ll show you a small part of that biodiversity. It will start with a crash course in Kansas ecology and discuss some of our native wildlife. 

Before we continue, please like and subscribe to learn more about North America’s wildlife history. 

As you travel across the state, you’ll go from forests in the east to the short grasses of the Great Plains in the west. In between are tallgrass and mixed grass prairies. Those prairies are named for, you guessed it, how tall the grasses are. The vegetation follows annual rainfall, with eastern Kansas getting the most and western the least.

Like the rain, we’ll go east to west in this video. I’ll highlight black bears, elk, and grizzly bears. All three are animals people don’t typically associate with Kansas. 

In eastern Kansas, black bears were the largest predator. Historically, they occupied the eastern half of the state while grizzly bears dominated western Kansas. 

Black bears are omnivores, so they eat a wide variety of nuts, berries, grasses, insects, fish, and mammals. They were more widespread in Eastern Kansas because the forests provided them with abundant food and shelter.

Unfortunately, black bears vanished within 30 years of Kansas becoming a state. The last official bears were killed in the 1880s though they started disappearing a couple of decades before that. 

They were uncommon enough that when a bear was shot near Cottonwood Falls, KS, in 1866, some locals speculated about where it came from. The Daily Kansas Tribune shared the story on October 10th, 1866. 

It was a lone bear who wandered onto Mr. Fisher’s prosperity. His gun failed to go off, so “Messrs, Fisher, Jonathan Wood, and other citizens of Chase County” chased the bear down and killed it. 

According to the paper, they didn’t know where the bear had come from, which led to speculation that the bear was an escaped pet from “somewhere up the Cottonwood.”

If bears were an everyday occurrence, I doubt there would have been speculations about their origin. Our next species was much easier to spot, and no one could confuse them for someone’s pet. 

Elk were creatures of the Great Plains and called all of Kansas home. Americans pushed elk up into mountainous areas. 

You may think about majestic elk bugling in the Rocky Mountains, but these huge cervidaes were the dominant deer species on the Plains.

Sources show elk were mostly found in the Tallgrass Prairie but were eliminated by the 1830s. After that, elk in the mixed-grass and short-grass prairies were killed off as Americans took over the rest of Kansas. By the late 1800s when elk were officially eliminated in Kanas. Like bison, elk were a casualty of market hunting and the quest for civilization. 

Wild elk, black bear, and even a stray wolf have returned to Kansas, but our last species has not and probably never well. 

I compared the Great Plains to the African Veldt at the beginning of this video, and the mighty grizzly bear brings that comparison home. The grizzly bear is our lion, tiger, or great white shark. 

They are our link between the current neutered Great Plains and the historic wild country that stretches between the Rocky Mountains and the Mississippi River. 

Grizzlys tended to stay within river basins where they would have found food, shelter, and water. We know through historical accounts that grizzlies were found throughout the state, but physical evidence is rare. I could only find one story where sisters found a grizzly skull along the Arkansas river in south-central Kansas. It was approximately 16 inches by 8.5 inches.

A vivid description of a grizzly bear hunt happened in a similar environment along the Missouri River in Montana. It occurred in 1874, and William de la Montagne Cary witnessed it from a steamboat headed up the river. 

He wrote that “about a mile off an immense grizzly bear [was] making for a cottonwood miles away and behind the bear came two men superbly mounted, armed to the teeth… We could see distinctly the horses straining every muscle to overtake the bear who was equally anxious and making every effort to escape his pursuers.”

Removing grizzlies represented the ultimate taming of the Great Plains. After they were wiped out of Kansas in the mid-1800s, no other predator could truly threaten people. The last removing wolves were killed in the early 20th century, leaving coyotes as the largest mammalian predator in Kansas. In typical American fashion, we tried to kill them off, also. 

Every time one of these keystone species was eliminated, Kansas became quieter. We Americans took this once grandiose landscape and domesticated it to the point where it's almost unrecognizable in the 21st century. 

If you enjoyed this video, please subscribe to get notified when new videos are published. In February, I will talk about coyotes. Thank you for watching.

Citations

Dan Flores American Serengeti

Fort Hays State Mammal Atlas

 The Daily Kansas Tribune, 10/25/1866. 
 Historical and Current Status of Elk in Kansas, University of Nebraska

https://www.kwch.com/content/news/Kansas-sisters-find-grizzly-bear-skull-along-Arkansas-River-563213811.html

Footage

United States Fish and Wildlife Service

American Mammals 1

American Mammals 10: Elk

American Mammals 5: Black Bear and Javelina B-Roll

American Mammals 12 and 13: Bison

United States National Archives

Predators

Music

The following music was used for this media project:

Music: Sunny Morning by MusicLFiles

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/7813-sunny-morning

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

Acoustic And Mellow (loopable) by chilledmusic

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/8832-acoustic-and-mellow-loopable

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license


Still Pickin by Kevin MacLeod

Free download: https://filmmusic.io/song/5707-still-pickin

License (CC BY 4.0): https://filmmusic.io/standard-license

Artist website: https://incompetech.com